Exploring the expansive frontier of Red Dead Redemption 2 reveals numerous hidden secrets, including obscure collectibles that lead to legendary weapons. Among these mysterious finds is the Torn Treasure Map 1, a scrap of paper guarded by a hermit living far off the beaten path. Unlocking this multi-step treasure hunt requires Arthur Morgan to locate two distinct halves before piecing together the final location of Otis Miller's revolver.

Locating the Hermit's Cabin in West Elizabeth

To begin the search for Torn Treasure Map 1, head to the far western edge of Little Creek River in West Elizabeth. Tucked deep within the dense woods, you will find a solitary wooden cabin inhabited by an aggressive hermit. Keeping up with daily gaming news often helps open-world enthusiasts uncover such hidden encounters without missing key details.

Approaching the cabin will trigger the hermit to warn Arthur to stay away before he opens fire with a powerful shotgun. Players should prepare for a quick combat encounter by staying behind cover and drawing a long-range weapon. Once you defeat the hermit, enter his modest cabin and search the nightstand next to the bed to collect the first map half.

Finding the Second Torn Treasure Map Piece

Completing the map requires obtaining the second half, which is located in a completely different region of the world map. Players must travel to the far eastern edge of New Hanover, just north of Annesburg, to find a isolated dwelling known as Manito Glade. Another hostile resident resides in this cabin, requiring caution upon arrival.

After dealing with the inhabitant at Manito Glade, search the small drawer inside the cabin to retrieve Torn Treasure Map 2. Combining both scraps in your satchel automatically forms the complete Otis Miller Treasure Map, revealing a sketch of the final reward's resting place. Reading the full document grants Arthur clear clues to head south toward New Austin.

Claiming Otis Miller's Rare Weapon and Rewards

The completed map points directly to Rattlesnake Hollow, a small rocky cave tucked away in the Cholla Springs region of New Austin. Players will need to navigate through the rocky bluffs until they discover a narrow crevice leading into a dark alcove. Inside, you will find a small wooden chest sitting quietly in the shadows.

Opening the chest rewards Arthur with the unique Otis Miller's Revolver alongside a stack of erotic photographs. This gold-plated Schofield revolver features custom engraving and impressive stats, making it a valuable addition to your arsenal. Completing this hunt offers both rich lore and a powerful weapon for your journeys across the wild frontier.